Thai Labour Campaign
Thai Language site Home page
News and Updates Campaigns Documents and Research Labour Laws Thai Labour Organizations Labour Links
Home
About TLC

 

 

Can Corporate Codes of Conduct Promote Labor Standards?
Evidence from the Thai Footwear and Apparel Industries

Violations of Codes of Conduct

The majority of the violations of the codes of conduct relate to excessive working hours, underpayment, denial of the freedom of association, suppression of trade union organizations, and inadequate occupational health and safety standards.

Piyavat workers demand compensation for over 700 laid-off workers in front of the Government House, Bangkok, March-April 1996.

The situation that Par Garment workers and union members face demonstrates that codes of conduct have not benefited many workers, especially in the apparel industry. The way that transnational corporations' labor standards are written and implemented are highly questionable. The codes of conduct state that the workers have rights, such as freedom of association and collective bargaining, however, as in the case of workers at Par Garment, the workers have had their rights denied.


The workers employed by the subcontractors are under-paid, forced to work long hours with no addition pay and no social welfare as many of the sweatshops are unregistered and therefore fall outside even the local labor law. Many of the sweatshops also employ children. Transnational corporations with conduct codes have not provided support or protection to either the workers at places such as Par Garment and Lian Thai or the workers in the sweatshops.

As manufacturers in the apparel sector produce many brand names it is very difficult to pressure the manufacturing companies to follow any codes of conduct. The manufacturer can always sell to someone else. The objective of the transnational corporations is to find the cheapest price per item, not selecting a manufacturer that provides the fairest treatment and welfare to the workers. The transnational corporations do not want to increase their costs by pressuring the manufacturer into following conduct codes. Instead, the transnational corporations tend to turn a blind eye to labor abuses. If transnational corporations are not willing to pay more for production to ensure that conduct codes are adhered to, the workers in these industries will continue to struggle to find enough money for food and clothing. Their children's education will suffer, and their health will continue to deteriorate. The workers suffer while transnational corporations continue to gain more revenue and enjoy their prosperity.

The workers who make Reebok, Nike or Adidas shoes, which cost over $US 50 in retail outlets, never get the chance to wear them. The management, on the other hand, at the corporate offices of Reebok and Nike are given newly released shoes for free. At the minimum wage, purchasing a pair of the shoes they make is not possible. Even if they could buy them, the workers would not wear these shoes for fear of being accused by their employer of stealing them. Business is about making profit and finding the cheapest cost of production for the highest profit, but when this profit is made at the expense of the workers' welfare, health, and life, it is criminal.

Previous Section:
Return to:
Next Section:

Top